Filing an insurance claim seems like the obvious response when something goes wrong, but it is not always the smartest financial move. Using your coverage can trigger a premium increase, affect your claims history, or even lead to a non-renewal. Sometimes paying out of pocket costs less in the long run. Here is how to decide when to file and when to keep your insurer out of it.
Your deductible is the amount you pay before coverage kicks in. If the repair cost is only slightly above your deductible, the math rarely works in your favor. A $1,800 roof repair with a $1,500 deductible means your insurer pays just $300—but the claim on your record could raise your annual premium by far more than that over the next several years. As a general rule, if the damage is less than twice your deductible, think hard before filing.
Insurers track claims history using a database called CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange), and your report stays active for up to seven years. Multiple claims in a short period can lead to non-renewal, especially in states like Florida where carriers already scrutinize their books closely. Even a single small claim can shift you from a preferred tier to a higher-rate tier at renewal. Consider the long-term cost, not just the immediate payout.
If you accidentally cause minor damage—a small dent in a neighbor's fence, a cracked windshield on a parked car—and the cost is manageable, paying directly may be the better route. Before agreeing to anything:
There are times when filing is clearly the right call. Major losses—a house fire, a significant roof collapse, a serious auto accident with injuries—are exactly what insurance is for. Liability claims involving injury to another person should always go through your insurer regardless of cost, because the ultimate exposure can be far greater than it initially appears. When the loss is large, unpredictable, or involves another party's injury, file without hesitation.
The decision to file a claim is not always straightforward, and the wrong choice can cost you more than the damage itself. A Truscott policy checkup can help you understand your current deductibles, review your claims history, and think through the financial impact before you call your insurer. Reach out before you file—sometimes a five-minute conversation saves you thousands over the life of your policy.
Comparing insurance quotes on price alone is a common and costly mistake. Learn what to look for in coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, and carrier strength to find real value.
Claims and ShoppingAssignment of benefits lets you sign over your insurance claim rights to a contractor or service provider. Learn how AOB works, when it helps, and when it can seriously backfire.